Goodwill Reviews
Goodwill Overview
The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.
Goodwill reviews show a 1.6 star rating from 788 customer reviews, 12% would recommend, 82% unfavorable; consumers are mostly dissatisfied with pricing and customer service.
Key Takeaways for Future Customers
- Expect inconsistent pricing and reported price gouging.
- Prepare for difficult returns and customer complaints about refunds and policies.
- Compare thrift options; some shoppers still find occasional good bargains.
Negative Feedback / Risk Areas
- Repeated reports of rude employees and poor customer service.
- High prices on donated items and inconsistent discounts.
- Stores described as dirty, disorganized, and understaffed.
- Poor phone support and issues with online auctions and shipping.
Positive Feedback
Some customers report good bargains and reasonable prices at certain locations.
The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.
Goodwill reviews show a 1.6 star rating from 788 customer reviews, 12% would recommend, 82% unfavorable; consumers are mostly dissatisfied with pricing and customer service.
Key Takeaways for Future Customers
- Expect inconsistent pricing and reported price gouging.
- Prepare for difficult returns and customer complaints about refunds and policies.
- Compare thrift options; some shoppers still find occasional good bargains.
Negative Feedback / Risk Areas
- Repeated reports of rude employees and poor customer service.
- High prices on donated items and inconsistent discounts.
- Stores described as dirty, disorganized, and understaffed.
- Poor phone support and issues with online auctions and shipping.
Positive Feedback
Some customers report good bargains and reasonable prices at certain locations.
Media from reviews





Nasty witch with white hair thinks she’s god rude big mouth
Nasty manager with white hair looks like a witch treated poorly told I changed tags when I didnt what a rip off never returning again the store is dirty
User's recommendation: Never go there they rip you offf
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |Greed
- - Goodwill pricing is seen as greedy.
- - Prices should stay affordable to help low-income shoppers and curb fast fashion's climate impact.
My experience with goodwill is interesting. I find amazing clothes, cute things, etc.
So i think to myself: i think im going to get this and then i look at the price tag, and it is 7 *** dollars for a tank top. This is genuine greed. You get these items for free. Thrift stores are supposed to be low pricing to help people in need.
Now people with low income (like me) lean on shein and temu. You know what that does? it defeats the purpose of buying from thrift stores to help with the mass amounts of clothing in the united states. this does not help climate and our environment.
Because why am i spending 40$ on a couple items? You know what business that actually cares about their customers? Salvation army. low pricing, amazing sales, always donating to charities.
1.99-2.99$ for a regular sweater! thats what we want to see in goodwill.
I think this business, goodwill should actually look at the reviews from costumers and take into consideration to change, because a majority of them would say the same thing as me. Do better.
Preferred solution: Price reduction
User's recommendation: don’t go to goodwill unless they actually change their prices. go to salvation army instead.
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |I was insulted by one of employees
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
- - Bought 4 items; sizes were too small after trying at home.
- - Returned for exchange; staff questioned the reason and the manager reviewed cameras while I waited.
I went into the store two days ago and bought 4 items: 2 shirts and 2 pairs of pants. I was in a rush to get back to work since I was on my break, and I forgot to try the clothing on.
When I got home, I realized the clothing was too small, so I went and processed a return at the store today. I was advised that they had to get the manager to do the return. She looked at the receipt and said, 'Why are you returning everything?' I said, 'What does it matter? I'm exchanging them for different items since y'all don't do cash back.' She said, 'Hold on, let me go and review the cameras.' I said, 'What for?
The items are there with the tags still attached and the receipt.' I felt highly offended because she was accusing me of stealing.
Then she had me wait there for 20 minutes and proceeded back, then asked me if I was the person who bought the items. I said, 'You went back there for 20 minutes and reviewed the cameras.
- I love that they have great items for great prices
- Rude mangers like that need to be removed
Preferred solution: Full refund and she need to be removed from Manger or i will sue for defamation of character i will all the i spend pleanty money here this was extremely unprofessional and ahe did in front of people and employees and other customers
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |I had a really unpleasant experience at...
- - Goodwill Center, TX: staff were rude.
- - The employee blocked placing a heavy item.
- - Checkout had Spanish chat about the item; I felt uneasy.
I had a really unpleasant experience at Goodwill in Center, TX, today. When I asked one of the employees, Elsa, if I could place a heavy item on the counter because I was still shopping and it was too large to carry in the cart, she asked if I was planning to purchase it.
I said yes, but she replied, 'Then put it in your cart.' So I had to find a way to make it fit. This is not the first time this employee treated me this way; she has a bad attitude and she is rude. During checkout, she chatted with another customer in Spanish about how old and unattractive one of the items that I was purchasing was. Even though I speak Spanish, I felt uneasy and anxious.
I usually love thrift stores, but this experience will be tough for me, especially since I have anxiety and depression and I use thrifting as a form of therapy. I usually spend a good amount of money every time I go there.
To be exact, I spend about $180 on this day. I would appreciate it if you talked to your employees to treat customers with kindness and respect.
- Finding affordable merchandise
- Discounted prices
- Rude taking an item from customer
Preferred solution: Apology
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerHorrible employees
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
Your employees treat people so bad at this store I don't know how it continues to run, I should sue your entire company for the way I'm guessing one of your managers treated me today yelling at me in the middle of the store and calling my service dog aggressive for barking which is his job when I start to panic!!!
User's recommendation: Don't ever shop at this store.
Complain/ no tag price
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
- - Untagged vases caused price confusion.
- - Staff said no tag means $1.49, which felt humiliating.
- - Inconsistent signage affected the shopping experience.
Tried several times and were unanswered
This is the second time that I shop at goodwill in Silverdale Washington store that the vases do not have tags and I filled up my cart until I can not put vases anymore. But as soon as I went to pay for it I was told only the little vase not the big vases. I asked someone in the floor who is working on the area and said if theres no tag its $1.49. I spent hours to picked this vases and to be told different story is humiliating for me.
When my customer complained I made sure to listen to my customers and do what they want not what I wanted. After all customers should have the right to say about their sign on the shelf.
No tag $1.49 like what the floor workers told me. Thank you very much.
Helen.
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerDispute
- - The mom claims to be a lawyer; the daughter posts people on social media without consent.
- - The company gave no response after evidence was sent.
No resolution. They won't answer because they know they are in the wrong and i can sue for doxing, defamation of character, *** released on social media
Daughter posts people on social media without their knowledge. The mother's husband is a lawyer, and he uses his authority with someone high up at Goodwill Corp to keep her and her uppity mother from being banned when they should be. The daughter made a nasty comment to my husband and then cried wolf, saying he is following me. No, he was defending himself.
I sent tons of evidence to the corporation, pictures, etc. No response. I feel for anyone that marries the daughter. She is the kind you don't want in your family.
Miss entitled trash. These people own a business. The husband is an attorney, and y'all go to Goodwill to resell at higher prices. Business is slow, lol.
By the way, the daughter got some karma back; her purse was stolen at Goodwill, and I hear she cried and pointed fingers at other customers to blame. Now, why is she still not banned?
- Regulars upper corp pampers
- Only listen to one side of dispute
Preferred solution: At least an acknowledgement. They did us wrong. Showed favoritism
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |Deceptive practices
- - Yellow-tagged items did not get 50% off due to tag errors.
- - Used items, especially shoes, are priced high; donate elsewhere.
This business doesn't care if you don't like what they do. When an item is marked with an incorrect price they won't give it to you for that price.
Go do your shopping and giving elsewhere. There is a lot of money going to pay high priced executives at this organization.
They had put out a new batch of sunscreen with a blue code but had neglected to do their usual thing of changing tags so stuff does not go on sale. Any reputable business would honor the price they had neglected to change. This store charges high prices for shoes worn by others. Their prices on used items are as high or higher than retail stores that have to buy their new merchandise and not get it for free.
The CEO, Donn Gethens, made $575,947 last year. My conclusion is to find a better place to donate and buy.
- High prices and reprising to avoid markdowns
Preferred solution: Price reduction
User's recommendation: Find a better charity to donate to and purchase from.
This store in Statesboro, Georgia looked like a garbage can inside
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
- - Couldn't reach store by phone.
- - Statesboro GA store shelves were cluttered.
- - Only clothes looked decent.
- - Staff uncaring; they laughed when spoken to.
Tried to call, but they wouldnt answer. Listen to the menu pressed all the right buttons nothing.
I was calling about the store in Statesboro, Georgia. These people clearly do not care about their store or their jobs apparently because the shells were stacked with stuff you couldnt even look through it. It looked like somebody just went through there and threw everything all over the place the only thing that was halfway decent to look through was some of the clothes said something to the staff about it politely and clearly they do not care.
They laughed under their breath, thats OK employ people like that. Is your store.
Preferred solution: A clean decent store this is clearly not that.
User's recommendation: Use your local thrift stop stay away from a Goodwill
Employee purchases
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
Absurd amount of employee purchases are being made at the Benton Harbor location. They are not enforcing company policy. One employee mentioned how some workers work together on finding items and purchasing for resale.
User's recommendation: Ask for company policy
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |You suck at your return policy. You say you help people.I was told I couldn't have cash back on my return.It was up to the manager. He insisted to give me girt card.
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
- - Refund not given in cash; a gift card was offered.
- - The manager said cash back isn't allowed and offered a gift card; 45 minutes in-store yielded nothing.
I was told I couldn't have my cash back on my return.I was also told it was up to the manager He insisted he had to give me gift card.If your in the business to help people why wouldn't he give me my cash back.There was nothing else in the store I needed. I spent a good 45 minutes looking around the store.I couldn't see one single thing I would want.Why couldn't I just get cash back.
- Price are low
- Return policy sucks
Preferred solution: Full refund
User's recommendation: Don't shop there
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |The music being played in the store
The music playing in store was loud. Rap with the f word in it and some more words degrading women.
The store was in East Stroudsburg. Pa. 18301. The only think I could tell that the store was clean.
Will not be goj g back. No
User's recommendation: Spend you hard earned money else ware.
Horrible stores
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
Nothing but total junk in these stores now. They actually have dollar store items and are selling them for $4.
Can't get a decent pair of jeans anymore because they are too expensive.
Stores dirty, unorganized, horrible smell. I'm done.
- No pros at all
- Dirty store
Preferred solution: Price reduction
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |I was told to contact you about trash out side box
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
I was told to contact your organization about the amount of trash collecting outside the Goodwill box at the Harding store in Bristol, Indiana.
- To fall away
Preferred solution: get the mess cleaned up
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |I am contacting you because I feel this...
The reviewer tried to contact the company before posting this review.
The same item I bought said it was for three dolls then they sent message it was for only one day which they failed to send after being paid for it
I am contacting you because I feel this is price gouging. I contacted the Goodwill about this but was told it is different listing times, but it is for the same time. It shows on both listings the same item but double pricing on one, both in the same condition, same item.
- Got some good things
- High prices
Preferred solution: Price reduction
User's recommendation: Beware
The young lady at the counter was rude
Get rid of her, I asked where the restroom was and she said I couldnt use it because it had just been cleaned. As if I was going to make it dirty.
I work for ford but I like to to find odd things . And she screamed it out in front of the customers.
How rude . Her mother didnt teach her anything
User's recommendation: Never go there
About
, ,
Goodwill is a nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization. Each regional Goodwill organization has different initiatives designed to meet the needs of its local communities. In general, Goodwill organizations are nonprofit workforce development providers. The money raised in our stores is invested in Goodwill programs and services to help people learn new skills and begin sustainable careers. These services are free and designed to help our community members navigate life’s challenges to reach employment and long-term success. Goodwill programs and services are unique to the communities they serve based on the immediate needs of the local job market for both job seekers and employers. If you’d like to find out more about what your local Goodwill is doing, you can find the Goodwill career center closest to you and view their website using our career center locator. You can also read the stories of individuals who changed their own lives with support from Goodwill. For more details on the impact of the greater Goodwill network, view our annual report.
Goodwill is ranked 88 out of 1483 in Non Profit Organizations category
1902
USA, Canada
Companies Similar to Goodwill
Thank You for Your Reply! We are processing your message.
Your comment will appear after moderation
Shop at Salvation Army then. You solved your problem.